Someone watching?
Hit the ESC key at any time to hide this site. Privacy Tips
Call 1-844-762-8483
7NATIVE

Or Text 24/7

If you send a text, you will immediately receive a response notification that you will be texted back from a secondary number.
Standard text rates may apply.
Your information will be kept anonymous and confidential.

Roe v. Wade: Our Work Is Not Done

Posted
by StrongHearts Native Helpline
A political act aimed to restrict women’s rights, the Supreme Court of the United States (June 2022) overturned Roe v Wade (1973) leaving the onus of access to abortion on individual states. Since then, six states have taken measures to codify reproductive rights while other states ramp up efforts to abolish or otherwise restrict access to abortion.

“The Supreme Court threw out nearly 50 years of precedent in favor of politicizing the body sovereignty of women and girls,” said Lori Jump, chief executive officer, StrongHearts Native Helpline. “By asking states to regulate abortion, they are taking away the rights of women to decide what happens to their body. Six states have reaffirmed reproduction rights, but until all other states follow suit, women are in a perilous position.”

Voters In Six States Affirm Women's Right To Choose

To date, there have been six ballot measures addressing abortion in California, Kansas, Kentucky, Michigan, Montana, and Vermont where voters upheld abortion rights.

On Aug. 2, voters (58.97%) refused to amend the Kansas Constitution to declare that nothing in the state constitution creates a right to abortion or funding for an abortion and to affirm the state’s ability to pass laws regarding abortion. Instead, voters upheld legal precedent in Hodes & Nauser v. Schmidt (2019) that the Kansas Bill of Rights provides a right to abortion.

On Nov. 8, five more states took action to uphold reproductive rights of women:

  • In California, Proposition 1, Right to Reproductive Freedom Amendment - voters (65.75%) supported amending the state constitution to prohibit the state from interfering with or denying an individual's reproductive freedom, which is defined to right to an abortion and contraceptives.

  • In Kentucky, Constitutional Amendment 2, No Right to Abortion in Constitution Amendment voters (52.37%) opposed amending the Kentucky Constitution to state that nothing in the state constitution creates a right to abortion or requires government funding for abortion.

  • In Michigan, Proposal 3, Right to Reproductive Freedom Initiative, voters (56.65%) supported a state constitutional right to reproductive freedom, including "the right to make decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy, prenatal care, childbirth, postpartum care, contraception, sterilization, abortion care, miscarriage management, and infertility care."

  • In Montana, LR-131, Medical Care Requirements for Born-Alive Infants Measure voters (52.55%) opposed measures to state that infants born alive at any stage of development are legal persons; require medical care and to establish a $50,000 fine and/or 20 years in prison for violating said law.

  • In Vermont, Proposal 5, Right to Personal Reproductive Autonomy Amendment was overwhelmingly supported by voters (76.74%) to amend the Vermont Constitution to add language protecting the right to personal reproductive autonomy and prohibiting government infringement unless justified by a compelling state interest.

“Although voters have upheld women’s rights in these states, the majority of them passed by a thin margin,” said Jump. “Our work is not done.”

Pending Initiatives, Amendments and Referendums

Currently, there are dozens of pending initiatives, amendments and referendums. In Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Maryland, Massachusetts, Nevada and Oklahoma there were nine proposals that did not make the 2022 ballot. In New York, Pennsylvania and Washington, there are four proposals slated for 2023. And, in Florida, Iowa, Nevada, Oklahoma and South Dakota there are seven proposals slated for 2024. (See Sources links).

“It's unfathomable that in this day and age, women and girls must be cognizant of legislation rooted in misogyny and historic oppression,” said Jump. “The criminalization of abortion is an abuse of governmental power to deny body sovereignty. It is a cruel reminder of what Native people have endured for centuries.”

Historic Violence and Oppression

In Indian Country, Native woman and girls suffer the highest rates of stalking, rape, and femicide in the nation. Yet, Indian Health Services has historically prohibited and continues to deny access to abortions in Tribal communities. Without planned parenthood clinics, Native women and girls are at a higher risk of being penalized for seeking abortions in unsafe conditions. Rape victims are often shamed and blamed, and now could face jail time for seeking an abortion.

The History Behind the SCOTUS Decision

According to Leslie J. Reagan, professor of history and law at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign and author of When Abortion Was a Crime and Dangerous Pregnancies, historical record5 describes early abortion—as “restoring the menses,” a woman’s period. It was a normal practice in colonial America well into the 19th century. Abortions were illegal only after “quickening,” a term referring to when pregnant women could feel the fetus moving - said to occur between four and six months of pregnancy.

Professor Reagan, explained that Justice Samuel Alito was egregiously wrong when he used English criminal law from the 17th century to overturn Roe v Wade. He conveniently dismissed the distinction between ending a pregnancy before or after quickening wherein early America, abortion before “quickening” was legal under common law and widely accepted in practice.

Instead, Alito’s draft majority opinion uses 17th century Jurist, Sir Matthew Hale who “described abortion of a quick child who died in the womb as a ‘great crime’ and a ‘great misprision.’ See M. Hale, Pleas of the Crown-1736 which also defended and laid the foundation for the marital rape exemption. Hale8 wrote:

“For the husband cannot be guilty of a rape committed by himself upon his lawful wife for by their mutual matrimonial consent and contract the wife hath given up herself in this kind unto her husband which she cannot retract.”

The provision for marital rape emxemption may sound antiquated, but it was legal in many U.S. states up through the 1990s.

“Justice Alito and a handful of Supreme Court Justices upended abortion rights leaving women to defend themselves against a 17th century misogynist who didn’t believe marital rape was a crime,” said Jump. “It is our sacred duty as women to stand up for ourselves, for our daughters and granddaughters and to guarantee safety and body sovereignty for future generations.”

SOURCES

  1. https://ballotpedia.org/2022_abortion-related_ballot_measures. Accessed December 9, 2022

  2. https://www.cnn.com/2016/06/23/health/abortion-history-in-united-states. Accessed December 9, 2022

  3. https://www.ucpress.edu/book/9780520387416/when-abortion-was-a-crime. Accessed December 9, 2022

  4. https://www.ucpress.edu/book/9780520274570/dangerous-pregnancies. Accessed December 9, 2022

  5. https://global.oup.com/academic/product/abortion-in-america-9780195026160?cc=es&lang=en&. Accessed December 9, 2022

  6. https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2022/06/02/alitos-anti-roe-argument-wrong-00036174. Accessed December 9, 2022

  7. https://www.politico.com/news/2022/05/02/read-justice-alito-initial-abortion-opinion-overturn-roe-v-wade-pdf-00029504. Accessed December 9, 2022

  8. https://digitalcommons.law.ggu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=&httpsredir=1&article=1248&context=ggulrev. Accessed December 9, 2022

BALLOT PROPOSALS

2022 (did not make the ballot)
Arizona Right to Reproductive Freedom Initiative (2022)
Colorado Abortion Ban Initiative (2022)
Florida Abortion Ban After Detectable Heartbeat Initiative (2022)
Maryland Authorizing Health Practitioners to Perform Abortions Referendum (2022)
Maryland Right to Reproductive Liberty Amendment (2022)
Massachusetts No Right to Public Funding for Abortion Initiative (2022)
Nevada Parental Notification for Minor's Abortion Initiative (2022)
Oklahoma Establish Rights of Unborn Persons Amendment (2022)
Oklahoma No Right to Abortion in Constitution Amendment (2022)
2023
New York Equal Protection of Law Amendment (2023)
Pennsylvania No State Constitutional Right to Abortion Amendment (2023)
Washington 15-Week Abortion Ban Initiative (2023)
Washington Age of Consent to Receive Certain Health Services and Abortion Initiative (2023)
2024
Florida Right to Life of Preborn Individual Initiative (2024)
Iowa No Right to Abortion in Constitution Amendment (2024)
Nevada Parental Consent for Child's Healthcare Decisions and Medical Records Access Initiative (2024)
Nevada Parental Notification of Abortion Initiative (2024)
Oklahoma State Question 825, Reproductive Rights Initiative (2024)
Oklahoma State Question 828, Right to Reproductive Freedom Initiative (2024)
South Dakota Right to Abortion Amendment (2024)

Resources Resources

More from the press room....

StrongHearts Celebrates Seven Years of Advocacy
Vital Funding Increases Culturally Appropriate Support and Advocacy
Love Languages For December
StrongHearts Receives $100,000 Giving Tuesday Grant from San Manuel Band of Mission Indians
StrongHearts Honors Native American Heritage Month
StrongHearts Announces New Positions
StrongHearts Native Helpline: Six Years of Evolution
ICWA Upheld By SCOTUS Despite Claims of Reverse Discrimination
StrongHearts Supports Family Violence Prevention and Services Improvement Act
StrongHearts Embraces Blue Campaign Partnership
StrongHearts Raises Elder Abuse Awareness
StrongHearts Celebrates Six Year Anniversary
StrongHearts Responds To Gun Violence
StrongHearts Stands With The Black Community
Women's Right To Safety Denied
January Is National Slavery and Human Trafficking Prevention Month
Stalking Awareness Month Aims To Educate
StrongHearts Native Helpline Issues DVAM Statement
Impacts of the Roe v. Wade Decision
Two Donations Support StrongHearts Native Helpline
Showing Up in Support of Indigenous 2S+/LGBTQ+ Survivors for Pride Month
StrongHearts Native Helpline Publishes State Reports on Intimate Partner Violence Impacting Native Americans and Alaska Natives
StrongHearts Native Helpline Honors Our Missing and Murdered Indigenous Relatives on May 5
Supporting Indigenous Survivors and Advocates for Sexual Assault Awareness Month
StrongHearts Native Helpline Statement on the Violence Against Women Act of 2022
StrongHearts Native Helpline Observes Five-Year Anniversary with more than 20,000 Contacts
StrongHearts Native Helpline Welcomes Three Tribal Advocacy Programs
February Is Teen Dating Violence Awareness Month
Joint Statement: Teen Dating Violence Awareness Month
Stalking Awareness Month Statement
StrongHearts Native Helpline Announces New Board of Directors
Native American Heritage Month 2021 Statement
StrongHearts Native Helpline Becomes Independent Organization
Joint Indigenous Organizations Statement About the Gabby Petito Case
Indigenous Advocacy Organizations Issue Joint Statement in Support of Survivors of Violence for Domestic Violence Awareness Month
StrongHearts Native Helpline Statement for 2021 Domestic Violence Awareness Month
StrongHearts Native Helpline Releases One Year Sexual Violence Advocacy Report
StrongHearts Native Helpline Launches Project in Michigan
Assistant Director Position Open at StrongHearts Native Helpline
StrongHearts Native Helpline Releases Chat Advocacy One-Year Report
Call for Justice is Answered by New MMIW Unit
Joint Statement: STANDING AS RELATIVES WITH INDIGENOUS SURVIVORS AND ADVOCATES FOR SEXUAL ASSAULT AWARENESS MONTH
StrongHearts Native Helpline Launches Text Advocacy
StrongHearts Native Helpline Marks Four Year Anniversary
StrongHearts Native Helpline Announces Launch of 24/7 Operations
StrongHearts Native Helpline Receives 10,000th Call
New Tribal Division Speaks To Needs Of Tribal Nations
StrongHearts Native Helpline receives 2020 Heroes In Health National Impact Award From National Indian Health Board
Native Advocacy Organizations Release Joint Statement Recognizing Domestic Violence Awareness Month This October
StrongHearts Native Helpline Honors October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month
SCOTUS Affirms Reservation Upholds Jurisdiciton to Protect Native Women
Stacking Up The Numbers
International Day Against Homophobia Commemorated
StrongHearts Native Helpline Announces Addition of Online Chat Sessions with Advocates