Dedicated to Justice
In recognition of Native American leadership in the field of domestic and sexual violence, StrongHearts Native Helpline is honored to present its featured leader, Sarah Deer, J.D., a citizen of the Muscogee (Creek) Nation of Oklahoma. She is currently a University Distinguished Professor of Women, Gender and Sexuality Studies and School of Public Affairs and Administration at the University of Kansas, and Chief Justice for the Prairie Island Indian Community Court of Appeals.*
Finding Her Way To Justice
Sarah didn’t see herself walking in the footsteps of her parents, so she went to school with a desire to become an actress. Acting is known to be a highly competitive vocation, so she charted a new path.
“My dad was a lawyer and a judge when I was growing up and I didn’t necessarily want to go that route,” said Justice Sarah Deer. Her father is a respected tribal court judge for the Muscogee (Creek) Nation Supreme Court. Her mother is a teacher who taught middle school biology. She could have leaned into both professions, but decided early on that she wanted to walk her own path in life. A path that had already been carved by the ancestors long before she knew it.
Sarah Deer was born in Silver Spring, Maryland but was raised in Wichita, Kansas where she spent her high school years participating in History Day, debate, forensics, theater and volleyball. She took first place in public speaking and debate in the Original Oration competition and later enrolled at the University of Kansas where she majored in women’s studies and philosophy. Her future was beginning to take shape when she applied to be a volunteer advocate at a rape crisis center in Lawrence, Kansas.
Advocacy and Rape
As an advocate, Sarah sat through multiple jury trials and witnessed the unjust treatment of rape victims in the courts and surmised that it is no wonder that the number of rapes in America is so underreported. Victims of sexual violence were being revictimized by the legal system. This is when the seeds of justice began to grow and her goals aligned with the leader she was naturally inclined to be. A leader determined and dedicated to ending violence against women.
“I sat through a lot of cases and saw the difficult struggles victims were experiencing,” said Sarah “That's when I decided to go to law school.” Sarah committed to the cause of helping rape victims throughout the legal process. She studied the processes and procedures and began to imagine how prosecutors could do a better job in cases of sexual violence. Eliminating the element of victim-blaming was a top priority.
Victim-Blaming and Shaming
Victim-blaming is the attitude that suggests the victim rather than the perpetrator is responsible for the assault against them. Defense attorneys imply the victim’s own actions, words and/or dress provoked the attack against them. In reality, victim-blaming is a cruel attack on the victim that is not only baseless, but it is also traumatizing and an effective deterrent to reporting future attacks.
“All across the board rape is underreported,” Sarah explained. “There’s no way of knowing the percentage of people who do not report, but we do know how unusual it is for rape victims to call for help.” She added that sexual violence needs to be understood as a pattern that began with Columbus - when Native peoples were targeted, stalked and kidnapped. She stopped short of the gruesome details that caused historical trauma in Indian Country - though it is worth mentioning in brief.
Historical Trauma And Jurisdictional Loopholes
Columbus subjugated Indigenous peoples with genocidal tactics including torture, rape, dismemberment and murder so brutal that Native peoples could never forget the trauma of colonization. The lust and greed of colonizers, the religious assimilation, the degradation and dehumanizing treatment of Native peoples still prevail in racism and stereotyping. Those who survived the human carnage of Columbus often committed suicide. The aftermath continues.
Truth be known, Native women and girls have long been subjected to unjust treatment at the hands of non-Natives but those relationships were made even more complicated in the judicial system through either lack of jurisdiction and/or jurisdictional negligence on behalf of state and federal courts. These jurisdictional loopholes enable perpetrators who commit crimes on tribal land and against Native peoples to escape prosecution.
Sarah explained that in the legal system - tribal courts have not had jurisdiction over non-Native perpetrators who commit criminal offenses against Native people since the 1978 Supreme Court decision in Oliphant v. Suquamish. This is especially devastating in cases of sexual violence. Beyond that injustice is having an insufficient tribal police force - whose lack of access to resources is another barrier to justice.
Small Victories and Big Goals
In 2013, Sarah Deer’s testimony before congress regarding violence against Native women contributed to the reauthorization of the Violence Against Women Act wherein provisions addressed tribal jurisdiction over domestic violence cases and assaulting a police officer. While many applauded this legislation, Sarah saw those provisions as a step in the right direction rather than a victory.
“I don’t think we stop at piecemeal legislation. We need full and complete jurisdiction,” said Sarah who admits that tribal court jurisdiction over non-Natives is not easily taken to task especially in light of previous court rulings.
“My long-term goal is to overturn Oliphant,” said Sarah referring to Oliphant v. Suquamish Tribe, 435 U. S. 191 (1978) a United States Supreme Court case that determined “Indian tribal courts do not have inherent criminal jurisdiction to try and to punish non-Indians, and hence may not assume such jurisdiction unless specifically authorized to do so by Congress.
Sarah understands that the impact of that ruling has been a barrier to justice ever since. She explained that overturning Oliphant could take years if not decades, but to do so would make a clearer path to justice. Until then, she intends to stay the course and maintain her life’s goal to end violence against women.
In 2019, Sarah's work as a lawyer and advocate did not go unnoticed. As a recognized legal scholar, a university professor, and a dedicated activist for Indigenous women, she was inducted into the National Women’s Hall of Fame where she met Sonia Maria Sotomayor, Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. It is her most cherished memory and a highlight in her career.
Additionally, Sarah was named a MacArthur Foundation Fellow in 2014 and a Carnegie Fellow in 2020. She also co-authored four textbooks on tribal law and has been published in a wide variety of law journals. In 2015, she authored “The Beginning and End of Rape: Confronting Sexual Violence in Native America,” a culmination of over 25 years of experience working with survivors. It earned the Best First Book award from the Native American Indigenous Studies Association.
A Final Note
In the voice of an advocate to victims of sexual violence, Sarah shared a message from the heart.
“Being a victim doesn’t identify who you are. It’s something that happened to you,” said Sarah. “I want victims to know that the violence that happened to them may affect them, but it doesn’t define and can never change the core of who they are nor the value of who they are. It doesn’t matter if the sexual assault happened 40 years ago. There is hope and there are people who can help.”
"Oliphant v. Suquamish Indian Tribe." Oyez, www.oyez.org/cases/1977/76-5729. Accessed 21 Apr. 2022.